The short answer
Start with Research
Before you call anyone, define your project clearly. Know what damage you have and what you want fixed. For water damage, that might mean identifying the source and the affected materials. Write down your questions so you don't forget them during conversations.
Use local resources to find candidates. Ask neighbors, friends, or your insurance company for recommendations. Look for patterns in complaints, not just one negative comment. A single bad review may be an anomaly, but repeated issues are a red flag.
- Ask for proof of insurance and any required licenses.
- Request references from recent, similar projects.
- Look up complaints with the state or local consumer agency.
- Get at least three written estimates.
- Verify the contractor's physical address and phone number.
- Trust your gut if something feels off.
Ask the Right Questions
Interview each candidate in person or by phone. Ask about their experience with water damage specifically. Inquire how they handle unexpected issues, like discovering mold behind a wall. A good contractor will have a clear process and communicate it honestly.
Ask about their drying and dehumidification approach. Water damage often requires structural drying, not just surface repairs. If they dismiss the need for proper drying, that's a warning sign. Also ask who will be on site daily and how they handle permits and inspections.
Get Everything in Writing
A verbal agreement is not enough. Insist on a detailed written contract before any work begins. The contract should list the scope of work, materials, timeline, and payment schedule. It should also state how change orders are handled, since water damage repairs often reveal surprises.
Never sign a blank contract or one with vague language like 'repairs as needed.' Make sure the contract includes a clause that allows you to cancel within a few days if you change your mind. Keep a copy of everything, including all correspondence and receipts.
Watch for Red Flags
Certain behaviors signal trouble. A contractor who demands a large deposit upfront or only accepts cash is risky. One who pressures you to sign immediately or discourages you from getting other bids is not acting in your interest. Also be wary of those who offer to inflate the claim for your insurance company.
Check that the contractor has a physical presence, not just a cell phone and a van. Ask for proof of workers' compensation and liability insurance. If they hesitate or make excuses, that's a clear sign to move on. Your home is too valuable to risk on a questionable operator.
Protect Yourself During the Work
Once you hire someone, stay involved. Visit the site regularly and ask questions. Take photos of the progress and any issues. If something doesn't look right, address it immediately rather than waiting until the end. A good contractor will welcome your involvement.
Keep a paper trail of all payments and change orders. At the end of the job, do a final walkthrough with the contractor before making the last payment. Make sure all work is completed as agreed. If you have concerns, withhold the final payment until they are resolved.
Need help right now?
Water keeps spreading into floors and walls, so it is worth acting early. Calls are answered 24/7.
Call Now (414) 348-0250Frequently asked questions
How can I check a contractor's background?
Ask for their full business name and verify it with your state's contractor licensing board. Look for patterns in any complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau or your local consumer agency. Also ask for references and contact them directly.
What should I do if I suspect a bad contractor?
Stop work immediately and document everything: photos, emails, contracts, and payment records. Contact your insurance company to report the issue. Policies vary, and your insurer decides what is covered. If you believe fraud or theft occurred, file a complaint with your state attorney general's office.
Is it worth paying more for a reputable contractor?
Often yes. A lower bid may cut corners, use inferior materials, or lack proper insurance. Paying a fair price for quality work can save you from costly repairs later. Get multiple estimates and compare the scope, not just the bottom line.