The short answer
Review the Inspection Report
After the home inspection, read the full report carefully. Highlight items that affect safety, such as electrical hazards, roof leaks, or plumbing failures. Also note signs of water damage, which can lead to mold and structural issues if left unaddressed.
In a cold, snowy climate like Milwaukee's, roof and pipe issues may surface. If you live in such an area, keep an eye on attic or basement moisture. Use the report to build a clear list of repair requests, not a vague wish list.
Prioritize Your Requests
Not every flaw is worth negotiating. Focus on major problems like a failing roof, foundation cracks, or active leaks. Minor cosmetic issues, such as scuffed paint, are usually not worth delaying the sale over. Your goal is to protect your investment, not to nitpick.
Consider the age and condition of the home. An older property may have expected wear, while a newer one should be in better shape. If the inspection reveals water damage in walls or ceilings, that is a priority. Ask for a credit at closing so you can hire local water damage pros to handle the repair properly.
- Safety hazards like exposed wiring or gas leaks
- Structural issues such as foundation cracks
- Water damage or signs of mold
- Roof leaks or missing shingles
- Plumbing leaks or faulty water heaters
- HVAC systems that don't work
Make a Reasonable Offer
When you send your repair request, be specific. List each item, explain why it matters, and suggest a solution, such as a credit or a fix before closing. Avoid demanding a brand-new roof for a minor leak; instead, ask for a professional inspection and repair.
Sellers often respond better to reasonable requests. If you ask for too much, they may reject everything. A balanced approach shows you are serious but fair. Remember, the goal is to reach an agreement that works for both sides, not to kill the deal.
Respond to the Seller's Counter
The seller may agree to some repairs, offer a credit, or refuse certain items. Review their response and decide what is acceptable. If they offer a credit, compare it to the estimated cost of the repairs. If they refuse a major issue, you may need to walk away or renegotiate.
Keep communication open and professional. If the seller agrees to fix something, ask for receipts and a final walkthrough to confirm the work is done. For complex issues like water damage, you might ask for a credit instead of having the seller do a quick patch job.
Finalize the Agreement
Once both sides agree, put everything in writing. The repair addendum should list each item, who will fix it, and the deadline. If a credit is given, specify the amount and how it will be applied at closing. This protects you if the seller fails to follow through.
Before closing, do a final walkthrough to verify all agreed repairs are complete. If something is missing, address it immediately. If you plan to handle repairs yourself, such as drywall replacement or roof repair, budget accordingly. A clear agreement prevents surprises after you move in.
- Include a deadline for repairs
- Specify the credit amount, if any
- Require receipts for work done
- Do a final walkthrough before closing
- Keep copies of all documents
Talk to someone now
Water keeps spreading into floors and walls, so it is worth acting early. Calls are answered 24/7.
Call Now (414) 348-0250Frequently asked questions
What if the seller refuses to make repairs?
You can accept the home as-is, ask for a price reduction, or walk away. If the issue is serious, such as a roof leak, a credit may be better so you can hire a qualified pro. Weigh the cost of repairs against the home's value.
Can I negotiate repairs after closing?
Once you close, the seller is generally not responsible for repairs unless fraud is involved. That is why you should address all major issues before signing. After closing, you are responsible for maintenance, like fixing a leaky faucet or replacing drywall.
Should I ask for repairs or a credit?
A credit gives you control over who does the work and how. Repairs done by the seller may be rushed or low-quality. For water damage, a credit lets you hire local water damage pros. Compare the credit to the likely repair cost and decide what fits your budget.